Super Eagles legend Mutiu Adepoju says he does not understand why an experienced player like Alex Iwobi was left out of the starting line-up for Tuesday's goalless draw with Tanzania in Zanzibar, though he believes Eric Chelle must have had his reasons.
The Fulham midfielder began on the bench at the Amaan Stadium as Chelle made seven changes from the 3-1 win in Uyo, and came on in the second half as Nigeria pushed for a winner that never arrived.
The point left the Super Eagles second in Group L, and Guinea-Bissau's win over Madagascar later that night has since moved the leaders three points clear with two rounds to play in March.
Adepoju: Iwobi has been in the team a long time
The former Super Eagles midfielder made his point in comments carried by Pulse Sports Nigeria.
I really don't know why an experienced player like Alex Iwobi didn't start the game against Tanzania.
Adepoju allowed that Iwobi might have been carrying a knock, and stopped short of condemning the coach.
I want to believe the coach must have a reason for the changes against Tanzania.
He also said he still expects Nigeria to reach AFCON 2027, with everything resting on the games against Madagascar and Guinea-Bissau.
What Chelle said after the draw
Chelle had already explained the selection at his post-match press conference, insisting it was a tactical call rather than a fitness issue. Nigeria lined up in a flat 4-4-2, with Fisayo Dele-Bashiru and Wilfred Ndidi in the middle, and the coach said the heat ruled out a high press.
We're playing 4-4-2 flat. It's not a question.
He added that the changes came “because the weather was very hot”, and put the blame for the result on his forwards: “This is not a question: we have to finish. We have to be more aggressive.”
Analysis: Why the Iwobi question will follow Chelle into March
Adepoju's view carries weight because it is not a pundit's attack. He gives Chelle the benefit of the doubt, and still cannot see the logic of starting without the squad's most experienced creator in a game Nigeria needed to win.
Chelle's reasoning holds together on its own terms: a flat 4-4-2 built to sit off in the heat needs legs in midfield more than a playmaker. The trouble is the outcome. A side that had to win, and that the coach himself said must finish better, spent the first half without the player most likely to create the chances he wanted finished.
That makes the Madagascar trip in March the real test. If Nigeria need goals and wins from both of their last two games, a starting midfield without Iwobi would need a very clear explanation, and the Fulham man's form for his club before then would only sharpen the debate. His own view on consistency before Zanzibar showed a player who expected to play a leading role.
The next Super Eagles window is the March double-header that will decide the group, and Iwobi's name on Chelle's first team sheet will be the first thing Adepoju and every Nigerian fan look for.